What a gas station stop reminded me about advertising, media and memory recall.
We were on our way to the lake when we stopped for gas. Nothing unusual about that. We have
made that drive many times, and a gas station somewhere along the highway in Northwestern Ontario is not exactly where I expect to find a marketing lesson.
But there it was: a little vintage red Ford truck.
It wasn’t advertising anything to me. There wasn’t a campaign behind it, a headline, a call to action or
a media plan. It was simply parked there, and I noticed it immediately.
The colour. The shape. The simplicity of it.
For somebody who has spent more than 25 years thinking about what makes people notice things,
that is difficult to ignore. Sometimes the best marketing lessons really do show up in unexpected
places.
Before people can remember us, they have to notice us.
And maybe that is partly why I keep noticing these things myself. Lately, I seem to be finding little
marketing and advertising lessons everywhere in places, objects and ordinary moments around
me. Heck, I might be doing exactly that right now.
Distinctiveness Comes First
We talk a lot about frequency in media. How many times should somebody see an ad? How much
reach do we need? How much frequency should we build before the campaign begins to wear out?
Those are important questions. I ask them constantly.
But frequency has to have something to work with.
That little red truck did not need five exposures before I noticed it. One was enough. It stood apart
from everything surrounding it.
That does not mean brands should abandon frequency. Quite the opposite. Repetition matters
because it helps reinforce something that has already begun forming in somebody’s memory. But
repetition cannot rescue something people barely noticed in the first place.
Good frequency should reinforce memory, not manufacture it from scratch.
That distinction matters. We can serve an ad eight times and technically achieve our frequency goal,
but if every exposure is visually interchangeable with everything else the audience is seeing, what
exactly are we reinforcing?
An impression count tells us an ad was delivered. It does not tell us whether anything stayed behind.
And Then There is the Colour
Imagine the exact same truck in black. Or white. Or silver. Colours we see on so many vehicles
today.
It would still be a beautiful old truck. But would I have noticed it in quite the same way?
Probably not.
And I definitely do not think I would be sitting on my couch late on a Wednesday evening writing an
article about it. I would probably be watching TV instead, not thinking about marketing at all.
The red separated the truck from everything around it. That is what distinctiveness can do for a brand too. It gives the eye somewhere to go and gives memory something to hold onto.
The truck was not trying to be subtle. And maybe that is part of why it worked on me.
Sometimes the Answer is Less
Advertising has a strange habit of accumulating things: one more benefit, one more offer, one more
feature, one more sentence, one more disclaimer.
Eventually, we have asked one piece of creative to do the work of an entire brochure. Then we
wonder why nothing stands out.
The truck was almost the opposite. There was not very much to process. Its colour and shape did
most of the work.
Creative does not always need more. Sometimes it needs room and boldness.
And that can be surprisingly hard for marketers. We get nervous about putting all of our gems in one
bold basket. We start thinking: what if this other idea works too? Maybe we should keep both. Or
three. Just in case.
Before long, instead of choosing the strongest idea, we are asking several ideas to compete inside
the same piece of creative.
Or worse, we introduce three, sometimes even more, different creative executions because none
of them feels bold enough to carry the campaign on its own.
And this is where I may sound a little critical.
I do wonder whether we have become more cautious about pushing creative boundaries. At least in
the market I work in, I see a lot of perfectly competent work that feels safe.
Maybe that is partly because making one strong choice feels risky. Sometimes it is simply easier to
play it safe. Safer work usually needs less defending, less explaining and less selling internally or to
the client.
But there is an irony in that.
If the idea is genuinely strong, clear and bold, maybe it should not need that much selling in the first
place. People should be able to see what makes it work.
And when we choose safety because it is easier to approve, we may also be choosing something
easier to ignore.
By trying not to make the wrong choice, we can end up avoiding a memorable one.
That, to me, is the bigger risk.
The Environment Did Half the Work
There was another reason the truck caught my attention: where it was.
Imagine that exact same truck parked at a vintage Ford show between twenty other beautifully
restored red trucks. Would it have stood out in the same way?
Probably not.
At that gas station, surrounded by ordinary vehicles, fuel pumps, highway signs, trees and the
scenery of Northwestern Ontario, it became the thing my eye went toward.
The truck had not changed. Its context had.
That is an important media-planning lesson.
Placement is not simply about finding somewhere an advertisement can appear. The environment
changes how the advertising is experienced.
A beautiful thirty-second video on a television screen in someone’s living room is experienced
differently from the same idea squeezed into a small placement somebody scrolls past on a phone. A
message encountered while somebody is actively looking for an answer behaves differently from a
message appearing while they are relaxing and watching entertainment.
Even excellent creative can struggle in the wrong environment.
Strong creative gives people something worth noticing. Media gives it the right place to be noticed.
That is why I have never thought of media planning as simply buying available inventory. It is about
choosing the environment where the message has the best chance to do its job.
We are choosing where an idea gets its chance.
And Then Frequency Gets to Do its Job
Which brings me back to frequency.
I am probably never going to stop talking about it.
Especially in digital media, I see campaigns spread so thinly across audiences, platforms and tactics that people may barely encounter the advertising before the campaign disappears.
One exposure is rarely enough to build memory recall.
But there is an important sequence here: first, give people something worth noticing. Then put it in an environment where it has a chance to be noticed. Then give people enough opportunities to encounter it again.
That is very different from simply delivering the same unremarkable impression over and over.
Frequency is not the idea. Frequency supports the idea.
And when the creative is distinctive, the message is clear and the environment makes sense,
repetition starts doing exactly what we want it to do: reinforcing memory.
The first encounter made that truck noticeable. Another encounter would make it more familiar. Another might make it easier to recall.
But none of those later encounters would matter very much if the first one had given me nothing worth remembering.
Maybe That is Why I Photographed the Truck
I did not know I was going to write about advertising when I pulled out my phone. I just liked the truck. Nobody asked for my attention. Nothing interrupted me. There was simply something distinctive enough in the environment that I wanted to look at it.
And maybe that says something about me too.
I pay a lot of attention to details. I notice colours, shapes, old buildings, signs, light, landscapes and tiny things other people might walk right past. I get inspired easily. I get in awe of things easily too. I often joke with my husband, Grant, that his world seems much simpler than mine. He can look at a place and just see the place.
Me? Oh boy.
My world is full of distractions. Beautiful distractions. Things that pull my eye, make me stop, make me wonder and make me think.
Sometimes it can be a little overwhelming, but I honestly would not want it any other way.
Because every once in a while, one of those distractions turns into an idea.
Or, apparently, an entire article about a little red truck at a gas station in Northwestern Ontario.